I am thinking about using this for my three kids I dont think my oldest daughter needs it, My 11 year old daughter has problems with spelling she is probably on a first grade level due to public schools. so I need to get her caught up so I was thinking about trying this program.

We just started using Sequential Spelling, found it cheap on ebay. My ds is not a good speller and still struggling reader and this seems to be working fantastic for him. Somehow this makes sense to him now and he can manage to spell words I don't expect him to get correct!

I noticed that was the spelling curriculum they are using in Sonlight which I am going to use next year for all my kids.

I have been using All about Spelling for a few years now with ds. I really like it. It is easy, low-stress for him, and works. He is a better speller than his sister was at that age for sure (and maybe better than she is now, at 18! ). I used Abeka and sequential spelling with her. I wish I had All about back then, I think it would have worked for her too.